(06-03-2012, 07:53 AM)DrPixel Wrote:

(06-03-2012, 07:15 AM)kman Wrote: For fuck's sake YES we GET IT, custom stories aren't as good as they used to be, but to be quite frank the sheer amount of complaining people are doing is getting more annoying than the stories themselves. This is seriously the second thread TODAY addressing this issue, not to mention people that intentionally find every bad story there is just to post about how absolutely terrible of a map it is (I won't name names, but you know who you are). Sure, when I see a story like that I don't necessarily approve of it, but it's not worth the time or effort to comment about how terrible each and every map that's not up to par with the best custom stories out there. If you don't like it, just move onto the next thread, it's really that simple.

Sorry if that came off the wrong way, it's just I've been getting really fed up lately with how much people have been complaining lately.

Bravo good sir, +rep to you.
No really, I gotta agree with you. The people who whine about how "custom stories are dying because of Pewdiepie" or "wow, [insert name here] has a shitty custom story obviously based on Pewdiepie, now we must shun him/her and tell him/her to get off the site" really irritate me far more than one person's lighthearted attempt to make a map for someone they adore. If someone actually goes to the effort of trying to learn how to make a CS then applying that to something they love, well, I say at least they learned something! Really, if you don't enjoy "lower quality" or "fan-made for Pewdiepie" stories, then just don't play them! It's honestly as simple as that and no discussion threads need to be made to complain about them, just let the mod creators do their thing and anyone who likes their CS (or wants to kindly critique it while NOT just blatantly saying they suck!) can talk about it on the thread while those who despise it can remain silent. It takes away all of the hate from this forum and leaves the base playing/creating of custom stories for Amnesia, which obviously anyone who's on this sub-forum likes, so we all have a common appreciation of something at least.

(06-04-2012, 07:41 AM)Dutton Wrote:

(06-03-2012, 07:53 AM)DrPixel Wrote:

(06-03-2012, 07:15 AM)kman Wrote: For fuck's sake YES we GET IT, custom stories aren't as good as they used to be, but to be quite frank the sheer amount of complaining people are doing is getting more annoying than the stories themselves. This is seriously the second thread TODAY addressing this issue, not to mention people that intentionally find every bad story there is just to post about how absolutely terrible of a map it is (I won't name names, but you know who you are). Sure, when I see a story like that I don't necessarily approve of it, but it's not worth the time or effort to comment about how terrible each and every map that's not up to par with the best custom stories out there. If you don't like it, just move onto the next thread, it's really that simple.

Sorry if that came off the wrong way, it's just I've been getting really fed up lately with how much people have been complaining lately.

Bravo good sir, +rep to you.
No really, I gotta agree with you. The people who whine about how "custom stories are dying because of Pewdiepie" or "wow, [insert name here] has a shitty custom story obviously based on Pewdiepie, now we must shun him/her and tell him/her to get off the site" really irritate me far more than one person's lighthearted attempt to make a map for someone they adore. If someone actually goes to the effort of trying to learn how to make a CS then applying that to something they love, well, I say at least they learned something! Really, if you don't enjoy "lower quality" or "fan-made for Pewdiepie" stories, then just don't play them! It's honestly as simple as that and no discussion threads need to be made to complain about them, just let the mod creators do their thing and anyone who likes their CS (or wants to kindly critique it while NOT just blatantly saying they suck!) can talk about it on the thread while those who despise it can remain silent. It takes away all of the hate from this forum and leaves the base playing/creating of custom stories for Amnesia, which obviously anyone who's on this sub-forum likes, so we all have a common appreciation of something at least.

I was about to post the exact same words, Its fustrating how people are reacting over something that eventually will disappear anyway?

(06-05-2012, 04:16 AM)Dagrocks Wrote:

(06-04-2012, 07:41 AM)Dutton Wrote:

(06-03-2012, 07:53 AM)DrPixel Wrote:

(06-03-2012, 07:15 AM)kman Wrote: For fuck's sake YES we GET IT, custom stories aren't as good as they used to be, but to be quite frank the sheer amount of complaining people are doing is getting more annoying than the stories themselves. This is seriously the second thread TODAY addressing this issue, not to mention people that intentionally find every bad story there is just to post about how absolutely terrible of a map it is (I won't name names, but you know who you are). Sure, when I see a story like that I don't necessarily approve of it, but it's not worth the time or effort to comment about how terrible each and every map that's not up to par with the best custom stories out there. If you don't like it, just move onto the next thread, it's really that simple.

Sorry if that came off the wrong way, it's just I've been getting really fed up lately with how much people have been complaining lately.

Bravo good sir, +rep to you.
No really, I gotta agree with you. The people who whine about how "custom stories are dying because of Pewdiepie" or "wow, [insert name here] has a shitty custom story obviously based on Pewdiepie, now we must shun him/her and tell him/her to get off the site" really irritate me far more than one person's lighthearted attempt to make a map for someone they adore. If someone actually goes to the effort of trying to learn how to make a CS then applying that to something they love, well, I say at least they learned something! Really, if you don't enjoy "lower quality" or "fan-made for Pewdiepie" stories, then just don't play them! It's honestly as simple as that and no discussion threads need to be made to complain about them, just let the mod creators do their thing and anyone who likes their CS (or wants to kindly critique it while NOT just blatantly saying they suck!) can talk about it on the thread while those who despise it can remain silent. It takes away all of the hate from this forum and leaves the base playing/creating of custom stories for Amnesia, which obviously anyone who's on this sub-forum likes, so we all have a common appreciation of something at least.

I was about to post the exact same words, Its fustrating how people are reacting over something that eventually will disappear anyway?

I am not a patient man ~.~
I also believe they won't go away because it just won't stop. Pewdiepie gets more popular. This means more talentless work. I'm not an idiot, I know that's not easy to say because I say it about myself, but this won't stop. Look at Minecraft. Do you think that's going to stop within the next few years? I don't.

(06-05-2012, 11:26 AM)Hardarm Wrote: Too bad people will get to know Amnesia as an unfunny game.
They don't imagine it's just some stupid mods setted up by players for their youtube idols or for stupid jumpscares.
Newcomers will just let it go and Frictional Games should do something. It's my opinion. The things can keep going as well >_>

(06-05-2012, 09:53 AM)andyrockin123 Wrote: /agree with Traggey

Just because people don't have the necessary time to polish their work to the point where its on the same level as the original game doesn't mean its bad. For Christ's sake, modding is a hobby, it's meant to be fun! Why else would people be doing it? It's not like they're getting paid for it. Personally, I'm doing it for experience with scripting/mapping, which is something I feel I could do as a career later in life; if not, oh well, its pretty fun!

In my humble opinion, there is no amount of "talent" that goes into this, just time, which equates to familiarity with the engine and its resources, generally resulting it more detailed maps and advanced scripting. If I released any of my first projects, people would no doubt caps lock me to death, complaining how its a PDP or troll map because of simply how bad it looked. But, over time, my mapping/scripting skills have increased exponentially.

tl;dr It's a freaking game. You don't have to play it if you don't like it. If you feel so strongly on the subject, create your own 5 star mod.

(06-05-2012, 09:33 AM)Traggey Wrote:

(06-05-2012, 04:16 AM)Dagrocks Wrote:

(06-04-2012, 07:41 AM)Dutton Wrote:

(06-03-2012, 07:53 AM)DrPixel Wrote:

(06-03-2012, 07:15 AM)kman Wrote: For fuck's sake YES we GET IT, custom stories aren't as good as they used to be, but to be quite frank the sheer amount of complaining people are doing is getting more annoying than the stories themselves. This is seriously the second thread TODAY addressing this issue, not to mention people that intentionally find every bad story there is just to post about how absolutely terrible of a map it is (I won't name names, but you know who you are). Sure, when I see a story like that I don't necessarily approve of it, but it's not worth the time or effort to comment about how terrible each and every map that's not up to par with the best custom stories out there. If you don't like it, just move onto the next thread, it's really that simple.

Sorry if that came off the wrong way, it's just I've been getting really fed up lately with how much people have been complaining lately.

Bravo good sir, +rep to you.
No really, I gotta agree with you. The people who whine about how "custom stories are dying because of Pewdiepie" or "wow, [insert name here] has a shitty custom story obviously based on Pewdiepie, now we must shun him/her and tell him/her to get off the site" really irritate me far more than one person's lighthearted attempt to make a map for someone they adore. If someone actually goes to the effort of trying to learn how to make a CS then applying that to something they love, well, I say at least they learned something! Really, if you don't enjoy "lower quality" or "fan-made for Pewdiepie" stories, then just don't play them! It's honestly as simple as that and no discussion threads need to be made to complain about them, just let the mod creators do their thing and anyone who likes their CS (or wants to kindly critique it while NOT just blatantly saying they suck!) can talk about it on the thread while those who despise it can remain silent. It takes away all of the hate from this forum and leaves the base playing/creating of custom stories for Amnesia, which obviously anyone who's on this sub-forum likes, so we all have a common appreciation of something at least.

I was about to post the exact same words, Its fustrating how people are reacting over something that eventually will disappear anyway?

I am not a patient man ~.~
I also believe they won't go away because it just won't stop. Pewdiepie gets more popular. This means more talentless work. I'm not an idiot, I know that's not easy to say because I say it about myself, but this won't stop. Look at Minecraft. Do you think that's going to stop within the next few years? I don't.

Look at Minecraft? How is Minecraft related to any of this?
More ''talentless'' work simply means more to play for those whom enjoy these stories.
It does NOT equal less serious content.

(06-03-2012, 05:53 AM)Dagrocks Wrote: I've changed my mind from the original post because I think we should either have a way to filter serious/unserious custom stories, or to let people know they can post their Pewdiepie maps to his website. The only reason I somewhat angered about that before is because I was really upset that my friend left the forums because everybody ignored him and his story that I know he worked very hard on. He was sad because his map was surrounded by other maps that were stuff like TROLL MAP or something like that. Sorry if anybody was upset about the original post. I should have thought a little more...
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

(06-06-2012, 03:23 AM)XxRoCkBaNdMaNxX Wrote:

(06-03-2012, 05:53 AM)Dagrocks Wrote: I've changed my mind from the original post because I think we should either have a way to filter serious/unserious custom stories, or to let people know they can post their Pewdiepie maps to his website. The only reason I somewhat angered about that before is because I was really upset that my friend left the forums because everybody ignored him and his story that I know he worked very hard on. He was sad because his map was surrounded by other maps that were stuff like TROLL MAP or something like that. Sorry if anybody was upset about the original post. I should have thought a little more...
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Is this custom story made by your friend still up? If it's not a jump scare fest, I would love to play it.