+- Frictional Games Forum (read-only) (https://www.frictionalgames.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Penumbra: Overture, Black Plague & Requiem (https://www.frictionalgames.com/forum/forum-5.html)
+--- Forum: General Discussion (https://www.frictionalgames.com/forum/forum-20.html)
+--- Thread: The Best Penumbra? Vote! (/thread-13372.html)
The Best Penumbra? Vote! - TaCTiCaLxReFLeX - 02-16-2012
Okay here is how I think about it.... Fun, Scary ,Story, Overall
1.Penumbra Overture: 7/10 _______ 5/10 _________ 8/10 _______ 8/10
2. Penumbra Black Plague: 9/10 ____ 9/10 _________10/10 ___ 10/10
3.Penumbra Requiem: 3/10 ________0/10 __________ 1/10 ________3/10
In my opinion Requiem was a huge let down......... let me hear yours about the other penumbras!!!
RE: The Best Penumbra? Vote! - CorinthianMerchant - 02-19-2012
Requiem is my favorite!
RE: The Best Penumbra? Vote! - Unearthlybrutal - 02-19-2012
Overture or Black Plague.
Overture has the best atmosphere, but Black Plague was much scarier.
RE: The Best Penumbra? Vote! - BrooksyFC - 02-20-2012
1) Overture has some great puzzles and story.
2) Black Plague is a LOT scarier and has some cool puzzles.
3) Requiem I am yet to play, but heard it's not very scary.
I'll go Overture as I've completed it and the story and ending were amazing.
RE: The Best Penumbra? Vote! - darkely - 02-20-2012
I am not sure why people are rateing Overture and Black Plague's storys seperatley. The plot simply continues...
1. Overture it was good loved the story but the mines got repetitive -.-
2. Black Plauge has a great story as does Overture ...towards the end when Phillip...
Spoiler below!
3. Requiem playing it now.