Frictional Games Forum (read-only)
Unique Monster in Choir? - Printable Version

+- Frictional Games Forum (read-only) (https://www.frictionalgames.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Amnesia: The Dark Descent (https://www.frictionalgames.com/forum/forum-6.html)
+--- Forum: General Discussion (https://www.frictionalgames.com/forum/forum-18.html)
+--- Thread: Unique Monster in Choir? (/thread-5608.html)

Pages: 1 2


Unique Monster in Choir? - Childerich - 12-02-2010

Hi everyone,

I just came across this rather puzzling passage in Amnesia's Wikipedia entry:

"The Choir is also inhabited by a large unnamed monster who wields a massive knife and wears a bloodstained sack-cloth robe and hood, who is faster, stronger and more persistent than the other monsters. He is capable of killing Daniel in two hits instead of the three the others require, and will not leave an area for a very long while if he spots Daniel."

Can anybody confirm this? I remember encountering several monsters in the Choir, but I'm quite positive those were only "ordinary" Brutes.


RE: Unique Monster in Choir? - Som1Lse - 12-02-2010

It is the ordinary Brute.
Guess even Wikipedia fails now and thenSad


RE: Unique Monster in Choir? - Bourlingueur - 12-02-2010

Well, in my case, there is a brute in the Choir which stayed around for a very long time after showing up... maybe that's the one.

Not sure though. I really didn't felt like staying long in the Choir. :p


RE: Unique Monster in Choir? - Aphotic - 12-03-2010

(12-02-2010, 11:26 PM)Bourlingueur Wrote: Well, in my case, there is a brute in the Choir which stayed around for a very long time after showing up... maybe that's the one.

Not sure though. I really didn't felt like staying long in the Choir. :p

Really? I found the Choir quite relaxing.
Big Grin


RE: Unique Monster in Choir? - Som1Lse - 12-03-2010

(12-02-2010, 11:26 PM)Bourlingueur Wrote: Well, in my case, there is a brute in the Choir which stayed around for a very long time after showing up... maybe that's the one.
The Brutes in the Choir are ordinary Brutes.
If you check with the level editor you can see that there aren't any other monsters than the Grunt, Brute and Waterlurker.
There are however many Brutes in the Choir and that make many feel that the first one never disappears.
It does however.

(12-02-2010, 11:26 PM)Bourlingueur Wrote: Not sure though. I really didn't felt like staying long in the Choir. :p
Me neither, that level was really annoying.
But now I love it.

(12-03-2010, 12:51 AM)Aphotic Wrote: Really? I found the Choir quite relaxing.
Big Grin
Well it is relaxing after you've finished the game.
Then you know it rather well.


RE: Unique Monster in Choir? - Aphotic - 12-03-2010

(12-03-2010, 08:11 AM)Someone else Wrote:
(12-03-2010, 12:51 AM)Aphotic Wrote: Really? I found the Choir quite relaxing.
Big Grin
Well it is relaxing after you've finished the game.
Then you know it rather well.

I was being facetious, hehe. I absolutely hated the Choir, and was easily my most hated place to be.

EDIT: That was slightly redundant.


RE: Unique Monster in Choir? - Kein - 12-03-2010

It was normal Brute.


RE: Unique Monster in Choir? - Spooder Wekd - 12-05-2010

(12-03-2010, 12:51 AM)Aphotic Wrote:
(12-02-2010, 11:26 PM)Bourlingueur Wrote: Well, in my case, there is a brute in the Choir which stayed around for a very long time after showing up... maybe that's the one.

Not sure though. I really didn't felt like staying long in the Choir. :p

Really? I found the Choir quite relaxing.
Big Grin

You lie


RE: Unique Monster in Choir? - stevensonbak - 12-18-2010

The only time I ever saw a brute was in the Morgue, all of the enemies I faced prior to and after the morgue were Grunts and water monsters...
Had me thinking, "Wow, what a waste of a badass character model..."


RE: Unique Monster in Choir? - LoneWolf - 12-18-2010

Well i looked it up in level editor, the statement on wiki is a lie. It's a normal brute obviosuly and all brutes normally kill in 1 hit as far as i know and they break doors down in 1 hit i believe. So if its stronger why does it take 2 hits?

The person who wrote it is obviously a troll or an idiot.
Spoiler below!

The brute is in - the morgue, the sewer in three scenes i think. also its in that weird big area. Not sure if its in any other areas though.

But the grunt is used more often probs because it doesnt kill you in 1 hit.