Can you kill monsters by swinging objects?

**Mega Derp Man** · 03-09-2012, 02:03 AM

Well, you actully can kill monsters, but only in mods, custom storys like "pewdiepie's castle" (I just love backstabbing the grunt Tongue

), and like someone said in a previous post, disabled triggers.

**Stepper321** · 03-10-2012, 05:08 PM

Well, you could script it but youll hate to modify everything, since theres is an health, and damage script inside the grunts!

**Danny Boy** · 03-10-2012, 10:53 PM

how many times do i have to hear the "can you kill monsters in amnesia?" question... NO you can not kill monsters! no matter what you trown them to the face they will not die... at least in the original amnesia you can't... so enough of this dumb questions.

**Your Computer** · 03-10-2012, 10:59 PM

(03-10-2012, 10:53 PM)Danarogon Wrote: how many times do i have to hear the "can you kill monsters in amnesia?" question... NO you can not kill monsters! no matter what you trown them to the face they will not die... at least in the original amnesia you can't... so enough of this dumb questions.

They can be killed, they just don't have any death animation, so they just stand there in idle animation no longer with any collision (i.e. you can walk right through them). Enabling entity info even shows that the monster is in a dead state.

You don't have to throw anything at it to kill it, though. If there is something small that it collides with and collides with it constantly, the monster can end up killing itself. This is the easiest way to kill them, because it collides too fast for health regeneration to have any significant affect.

**Datguy5** · 03-20-2012, 06:41 PM

(03-10-2012, 10:59 PM)Your Computer Wrote:
(03-10-2012, 10:53 PM)Danarogon Wrote: how many times do i have to hear the "can you kill monsters in amnesia?" question... NO you can not kill monsters! no matter what you trown them to the face they will not die... at least in the original amnesia you can't... so enough of this dumb questions.

They can be killed, they just don't have any death animation, so they just stand there in idle animation no longer with any collision (i.e. you can walk right through them). Enabling entity info even shows that the monster is in a dead state.

You don't have to throw anything at it to kill it, though. If there is something small that it collides with and collides with it constantly, the monster can end up killing itself. This is the easiest way to kill them, because it collides too fast for health regeneration to have any significant affect.

That has happened to me a few times Big Grin

**Danny Boy** · 03-21-2012, 01:42 AM

(03-10-2012, 10:59 PM)Your Computer Wrote:
(03-10-2012, 10:53 PM)Danarogon Wrote: how many times do i have to hear the "can you kill monsters in amnesia?" question... NO you can not kill monsters! no matter what you trown them to the face they will not die... at least in the original amnesia you can't... so enough of this dumb questions.

They can be killed, they just don't have any death animation, so they just stand there in idle animation no longer with any collision (i.e. you can walk right through them). Enabling entity info even shows that the monster is in a dead state.

You don't have to throw anything at it to kill it, though. If there is something small that it collides with and collides with it constantly, the monster can end up killing itself. This is the easiest way to kill them, because it collides too fast for health regeneration to have any significant affect.

yet that can only be seen as a bug....
so i keep my words... you can't kill monsters officialy in the original amnesia.

**TaintedRainbow** · 03-30-2012, 05:25 AM

(07-01-2011, 07:20 PM)Hunter of Shadows Wrote: They have no death animation so no

Well, actually, I've seen a bit of someone messing around with it... they found that he does have a death animation, and a rag-doll, but no true way to die... weird eh?

**Your Computer** · 03-30-2012, 07:39 AM

(03-30-2012, 05:25 AM)TaintedRainbow Wrote: Well, actually, I've seen a bit of someone messing around with it... they found that he does have a death animation, and a rag-doll, but no true way to die... weird eh?

It's not weird when we consider the real facts:

Rag-doll grunt was user-modified.

**Electra** · 04-02-2012, 05:31 PM

Even if you could kill monsters in Amnesia, I feel it would take away a lot from the game. Just like killing wolves in Penumbra Overture gave me a sense of ease knowing I could kill them with my pickaxe or a gas tank. Amnesia really ups your "gnawing on your fingernails till there's nothing left level" because there is no way to defend yourself. it's that feeling of helplessness that makes it even more scary.

**Desperate4God** · 04-03-2012, 02:54 AM

(04-02-2012, 05:31 PM)Electra Wrote: Even if you could kill monsters in Amnesia, I feel it would take away a lot from the game. Just like killing wolves in Penumbra Overture gave me a sense of ease knowing I could kill them with my pickaxe or a gas tank. Amnesia really ups your "gnawing on your fingernails till there's nothing left level" because there is no way to defend yourself. it's that feeling of helplessness that makes it even more scary.

I second that.