Isn't Amnesia one of the most scary games out there ?

[Googolplex]

Amnesia since was the most scary game ever made.
But after more than one year, too much people know that game and it becomes normality.
Amnesia is a very good and scrry horror game, but when you already know all game elements, it isn't really scary. Normally a grunt should let you feel panic, but when you play the game for fun, it is not scary.
It's a game you only can play one time to be scared. The atmoshpere still is oppressive in the second half, but when you already know that game, it's not more immersing, you automatically play for fun and doesn't concentrate on the game.

Amnesia only is scary whan you play it right, it's not a normal game what you can play for fun!
When you wants to be scared, you will. Otherwise not.