Horror games as good as Amnesia?

[spukrian]

Thief: DS of course had the infamous Cradle level which I actually find scarier than anything in TDP. It's just unfortunate that it has such horrible controls. I tried to replay it a few weeks ago and I just couldn't get into it. But still, that level is just unbelievable.

The controls are indeed quite weird, I remember being annoyed with how Garrett does this semicircle when switching from running forwards to running backwards. But eventually I got used to them.

The Cradle is a scary level, though it doesn't scare me as much as anything in the first game. I got quite creeped out by the Pagan level and the Kurshok level. And those endgame enemies scared me too.

Also IMO, whether you like Thief I or Thief II is just a matter of preference. Both games are equally great.

Agreed! Thief DS is a great game too, but doesn't really live up to it's predecessors unfortunately.