Making monsters of Silent Hill

[Googolplex]

Hey, great post in the spoiler.
But I have to say that Penumbra & Amnesia scared me more than Silent Hill.
Of course, all these games are scary in its own way. But the oppressive feeling was a bit more in Frictional. Perhaps it's important which game you will play first.

When playing Penumbra first, you will find it scarier than Silent Hill, but when you play Silent Hill first, you think Penumbra isn't so scary. A major problem of Silent Hill is that you can fight your enemies, instead of running away and hide, you have to run in front to them and fight.

I think, in a horror game you never should run in front to a monster, that's not the goal of fear.
But nevertheless, Silent Hill is scary enough to let you feel mental pains.

The environments, the sounds, the effects etc. I think there is no "winner", they all are winners.
But for sure, Silent Hill is the best 3rd person horror game for PC.