Conspiracy: Philip = Mass Murderer?

[Thaliur]

Does anyone else find it odd how..timely his mothers death was? No explination, just a sudden death. He didn't seem to have much emotion about it.

It happenend more than a year before he sends the message the players get to read throughout the game. After one year, you can talk much more calmly about things like that than shortly afterwards. Trust me, I know this.

However,that's just the tip of the iceberg.
In overture, there is a man in the old mines who's locked in the room. He is obviously frightened, and knows something is out to kill him. Philip senses this, and decides to "get out of the way" and let the monster kill the guy.

He couldn't get the door open, so he couldn't really help Dr. Roberts, and I don't think he would have been able to protect him from Frisk.

Not only did Philip not help a man who obviously needed it, he burned him alive. Yes, red may have 'seemed' like he wanted to die, I highly believe that he was simply delusional.

Even Clarence said that Red really wanted to die, and judging from his behaviour at other times, I don't think that was a lie. If he wanted to frighten Philip, he would probably have told him that the Tuurngait forced him to ask Philip to kill him.

The 'dead' man in the hallway (forgot his name; he's in the demo) could clearly be heard saying "help me" yet philip makes no move to help him. In fact, he steals some of the precious blood he has left.

Remember, Philip was most likely already influenced by the Tuurngait infection. The chief Chemist (forgot his name) did not move at all, and if he was able to talk, it's highly unlikely he was unable to move even the tiniest bit.

Philips Father; there were no signs of decay on him. It looked as if he was unconscious; does anyone else find it strange how Philip never checked for a pulse? Being locked in that room had probably made him dehydrated and was getting close to death.

Unconcious people and dead people, while similar in behaviour, actually look quite different, and Philip is a scientist, after all, an observer. And since "look at" in games usually equals "examine" I guess we can just assume that he checked the usual life signs.

Than, annibal. This is pure, cold murder at it's best.

Agreed. Philip did kill Amabel (unless she was dead before and Clarence just made you not see her corpse), but it happened while Clarence made him believe she was a Tuurngait, so it's hardly his fault.