What do you think is the #1 monster in the Frictional Games Penumbra & Amnesia?

[Robby]

Just a thought, but if you were the people creating Amnesia 2, what monster would you add?

Not sure, but I'd be making something that would probably fit into the universe the game takes place in. I'd also make sure the monster encounter would be freaky enough. So that players would fear the monster, not run into it as if it is just a hallucination.

I'd leave that up to someone who understands it better. Instead of creating something stupid, I'd rather get some ideas first.

Good points. I'm just wondering what they'd put in a game that has you in a city (as seen in the teaser for Amnesia 2).

Time will tell. But seriously, we should watch the topic (I mean, not to stray Off-Topic). If we go too far, this thread could get locked. And the thread's too young for that.

True, good point, so back to topic.

I've noticed the Brute has a huge lead in the poll. I guess its the combo of scary humanoid appearance, noises that creep you out, and a dangerous blade!

That makes the brute a scary opponent. An enemy that is nothing but strength isn't scary at all. It needs to "look" appropriately.
EDIT: Also, the first time I encountered him (The Morgue), the noises creeped me out completely. I knew I was about to face up with a terrifying enemy. Guess I was correct.