Tech Demo vs Overture vs Black Plague

[Petike]

My personal ranking for all the three games in the series - divided into several cathegories considering the design and gameplay :

Horror feel and atmosphere
1. Black Plague / Overture - it's a tie ;-)
2. Tech Demo

Action
1. Overture
2. Black Plague
3. Tech Demo

Puzzles
1. Overture / Black Plague - it's a tie
2. Tech Demo

Level layout design
1. Tech Demo
2. Overture / Black Plague - another tie, but BP seemed less predictable...

Philip's voice acting
1. Overture
2. Tech Demo
3. Black Plague

:-) That's my little opinion.


P.S. Last (and final) update : 10. June 2008