What the Heck's wrong with Requiem?

[Yuhaney]

I don't really understand why everyone have something against Requiem. Yes, it wasn't as scary as the first two games. Yes, there really wasn't that much storyline. But I was happy to solve some puzzles that I hoped to be more in the first two Penumbra games. (Though, it was pretty over shooting with some puzzles, since it became to be some sort of an "future" adventure-puzzle-game...)