second chapter of amnesia: horror game of the year or not ?

[Cuyir]

No commentary Icon is the only disappointing thing in your list, OP.

A:TDD was more or less that long (at least the good stretch of it was before it degenerated to meh) and everything else in the list is inconsequential.

Want custom stories? Keep downloading and playing them on A:TDD.

No fighting? It was horrible in Overture...

Lack of a little episode like Justine is a bit disappointing but oh well.