I literally just finished AMFP a few minutes ago. I fucking loved it. I saw a few posts before it's release saying how shitty it was going to be, but I forced myself to think of it as it's own game and stayed away from all the childish battering of it. I played it through 2 days, and finished it in about 3 hours. I found that I kept talking to myself in the game because I was honestly horrified. Some doors were just too menacing to walk through.
I also FUCKING LOVED the way they made you panic in this game. For example:
I really, really liked that part because I almost broke a sweat panicking. I was hauling ass while I was simply terrified. It was great!
The ending was also great I thought. Some things could have made more sense to end the game but it wouldn't have been as strong as an ending. The music was literally the most perfect choice I think they could've done. It sent chills down my spine while I was approaching the final area. I loved this game. I loved it as much as I loved any other Frictional Games masterpiece.
Good job, Chinese Room.
(Also, sorry I'm not a senior member, figured I was pretty close though.)