Opinions on how TCR & FG are dealing with AAMFP criticism

[Fortigurn]

What that really indicates to me is that the established fan-base is hating on a sequel that wasn't a clone of the first game. Give it a few more months and the scores should even out.

That ignores the detailed comments people have made. The most common objections are not that the game 'wasn't a clone of the first game'.

I think that if it were up to the fans, we'd have a story about Daniel going to another haunted castle and getting hunted by red goop. Again.

No, if it were up to the fans the player would be more involved in the game, would have their hand held a lot less, and would be able to interact more with the environment.