Would prefer a silent protagonist. [spoilers]

[norwegianboyee]

Personally, I don't think I could cope with a Silent Protagonist, but if Simon said lines which were a bit more... intelligent or of more common sense, I would appreciate him just that little bit more. I mean, most of the voicing when he is by himself is there so that the player knows/remembers where to go and/or what to do - and to be fair, some of us say random, not-so-common-sense based things when we are by ourselves.

But there are definitely times where I wanted it to just be quiet. Just me and the sounds of the environment.

Yeah... Talking to yourself is natural... I'm pretty sure i wouldn't when there are monsters everywhere though.
Also if we need reminders of where to go there is always a memento function, but are people (excluding LP-ers) really that stupid though?