The Water Monser isnt scary? It is, because...

[ploppytheman]

I think this could've been better handled by a constant swimming noise, rather than splashes like someone was jumping through the water. A swift, constant disruption of the surface like you get when a fish swims away quickly would've been more panic inducing I think.

But it still scared me s***less as is.

There was a noise every so often when you are out of the water to remind you where it was if you didn't notice that. You didn't have visual confirmation but audio always.

I think any constant effect when you were in the water would have been better than an invisible entity with a single splash.