*Spoilers* The Torture Victims

[Macil]

Which would give us interesting problem regarding personality. ... rational or irrational 'reasoning' when you explain what might have motivated a person to do X or Y.

@Mjarr

I don't understand. What's the problem with personality?

If we assume the amnesia potion causes irrevocable loss of all memory (pertaining to identity, not procedural memory) -- and we have every reason to believe this is true -- then Daniel committed suicide at the start of the game.

Without knowing more about the amnesia potion, then I would consider the "player" Daniel a new person -- who cannot be held accountable for the "old" Daniel's actions any more than Santa Claus.

A person is always themselves unless they're not themselves (i.e., dead), heh. I mean ... who else would they be?