Just finished Penumbra series and...

[Thanatos]

I've been trying to decide which I like best for a while and have decided that it has to be Penumbra u.u

It wasn't as scary and the graphics aren't as pretty (really the Satan dogs are kind of amusing looking once you get used to them) but I preferred Philip as a main character and the decisions he made. Basically if you take Phil and Dan out of the equation I like them both equally, but if you add them back in Penumbra takes it.

I couldn't really feel for Daniel and though he got scared and made bad decisions, Philip seems more real. I can understand why Phil does what he does, whilst Dan just gets on my nerves. I also felt that the fact that Daniel spoke all the time broke the immersion just a tad, I would have liked to pick up notes and things and read them myself. Whilst I'm rambling I shall add that I personally liked the heavy, hard to open doors in penumbra.

I would like a mix between the two n.n stick Philip in Daniel's world.