I must be crazy, but the prison didn't scare me *that* much

[Xss]

I kinda feel the same way: while Amnesia was probably one of the scariest games I've ever played, I didn't get that scared, but in my case it's simply because I no longer can immerse myself at 100% in a game (which is a shame, I probably ruined half of the game myself while playing it). As for the prison, I already started picking up the mechanics of the game (aka "a monster will appear everytime you complete an objective), so I was able to prepare myself in advance. Ie in the kitchen, one of the first things I did was to build myself a little hiding spot, in case a monster would appear...Which finally happened...And since the monsters don't search very well rooms, nothing happened to me. Not that I had a couple of shivers, and I admit it was probably the scariest level of the whole game.