A true opinion from the Frictional Games community

[hollowleviathan]

Penumbra is a different game than the horror-fest sanity-shatter that is Amnesia. It's a horror-adventure game, and should definitely still be a very fun experience in a world that holds Amnesia. Requiem is yet another step away from Amnesia, in that it's the puzzle adventure portion of Penumbra distilled into a unique experience. I'm all sorts of biased, but I think they're all excellent games, despite and because they're not all the exact same thing.