I get scared of horrors very easily. I was playing Metro 2033 and I was jumping out of my skin haha. IMO, I thought dead space 1&2 were great games, but more of an action horror, not that there is nothing wrong with that. I think the atmosphere was great in parts, but it was more jumpy than scary.
Thank you nackidno, I literally want a list of horror game suggestions, not any arguments
I've played Condemned, on the manikin level and one in a small house before burglars come in. That's a scary game, but I wasn't too keen on the combat, died a few times
Thanks guys for your suggestions, keep them coming and I'll check out the ones you've said.