What could happen in Amnesia 2?

[Kman]

I didn't like the floating alexander much, but I didn't mind because it's only at the very end.

The watermonster, I liked him, he was pretty original and although a bit unrealistic he was still made to be not very powerful and bound by certain rules (eg. can't leave water, can't get past doors without busting them open first).

The shadow just engulfs anything it wants, and it was a bit too obvious to me that it only so happened to convientently engulf the room you are about to leave, but just not enough so you stay alive. It was an entirely scripted mechanism of which didn't put any fear in me as I knew there is no way the shadow 'hunting' me would ever get me, except for the two predictable and easy chase scenes.

I'm sorry, but did you honestly expect amnesia to be totally realistic? The game isn't made to tell an in depth story, or to show off ground breaking puzzles, or be so realistic to the point you could imagine it happening in real life. No, it was made to make the player feel terrifyed. And all those three other things are kind of just added on to make the game better. But of course since they're just add ons to the original concept it's stupid to think that they would put NEARELY as much time into them as they would focusing on terrifying the player.