Oh god

[Xenomorph]

I just finished Black Plague and I agree 100% gray. Where I found the monsters in Overture to be tedious and annoying (and less and less scary) I found Black Plague to be more frightening than the scariest parts of Amnesia. The whole ending (aside from the very ending) was just me running blindly around to the rooms with horrible anxiety. While at the end I just out maneuvered the enemies I still found most of the sequences and areas to be highly creepy.

Once I finish the final game (haven't started it yet) I'll give me full review and suggestions. I have to say so far my list is as follows for scare factor:

1. Black Plague
2. Amnesia
3. Overture
4. Requiem (I suspect it take its place here, as I hear its not very scary)