Oh god

[gandalf91]

Yeah, I really don't know, what is more scary - Black Plague or Amnesia?
But I think, that Black Plague was a little more scary.
I've got nightmares of this game, captured in this dark building-complex.
Even if Amnesia meant to have more horror, Black Plague is more danger and creepy.
But Overture was the best of all games and all they are super scary (even Requiem).

But Plague was scarier than Amnesia to me in its early stages, however I felt the fear factor in Amnesia lasted longer, so it's a bit of a tossup. (I agree with OP, after the morgue Amnesia isn't nearly as scary. In fact, it still boggles my mind how some people found the choir to be the scariest area. That was about middle of the pack for me.)