"I Will Disagree" - Why do you have such a negative outlook on everything? You said that my map was probably not even worth playing, you say this guys map "probably looks like shit" why do you assume all this crap before trying it? I see you've tried, and reviewed his map now, and although it is very honest, there is nothing constructive in there at all.
I've not played his map ( a bit hypocritical I know
) but that doesn't mean I assume it to look shit. I prefer to enjoy the good aspects of a story rather than focus on the bad parts.
In Short: Maybe if you stopped acting so negatively all the time you'd enjoy peoples maps more.