Horror games as good as Amnesia?

[Bridge]

Seems like nobody here has played Thief. I've only seen one other person on this forum mention it.

I've played the Thief games lots of times. And I agree, The Dark Project had some incredibly scary levels. The sequels had less scares, but still had a lot of levels with really creepy atmosphere. With that said, I actually prefer Thief II, because the focus is on stealing instead of on "tomb raiding".

Thief: DS of course had the infamous Cradle level which I actually find scarier than anything in TDP. It's just unfortunate that it has such horrible controls. I tried to replay it a few weeks ago and I just couldn't get into it. But still, that level is just unbelievable.

Also IMO, whether you like Thief I or Thief II is just a matter of preference. Both games are equally great.