How do you rate Requiem? (or until now)

[Bloodbath]

I agree with Zeewolf except about expectations. I think after the end of BP, playing out the puzzles in Phillips own mind was a fitting ending.
Frictional games said Requiem was all puzzles and wrap up a few loose ends. That's exactly what they delivered. If anyone expected anything different, they just were not paying attention. I think we're all lucky as heckfire to have the final part of the trilogy.
I give it an 8.5. I thought the game was great. It wasn't as scarry as the others, but the puzzles were great,and you got to hear Red again.