[SPOILER] Which Amnesia do you like most?

[Ghieri]

The environment design is a lot more beautiful in AMFP, I'll give them that. However, the substance was rather lacking.

TDD is superior in:
Story: It made sense, even though it was a bit on the minimalistic side.
Level design: You were never corralled into a specific area, there were story-critical areas but the solution was never in front of you; You were left to explore and find the solution.
Horror: I got cold-sweats at one point. In MFP I just got mildly stressed.