[SPOILERS] - Your scariest part of the game

[Fletcher Christian]

Also, what really stood out and sticked with me up until now was that moment when I looked into the mirror at that Bathroom near the common room/living quarters at Theta. I think that was the first mirror in the entire game that was 1) not broken and thus 2) clickable, wasn't it?

It may seem silly but

Spoiler below!

the reflection gave me the most terrible scare in the entire game, despite knowing full well Simon was a robot. I KNEW that alright. But for some reason I was in no way prepared to have a full-blown homanoid robot stare right back at me. That's when it REALLY settled in.

Gave me instant goosebumps and I actually squeaked and nearly fell off my chair.