[MASSIVE SPOILER THREAD] The end

[Redeemer]

An important note is made in the author commentary in Daniel's room. All of the diary entries by Daniel were written before he took the amnesia drink, and thus they reflect his past feelings and opinions. After Daniel takes the amnesia drink, the player assumes the role of the new Daniel, and he/she is fully free to make decisions and judge the old Daniel on their own. Therefore, when the time comes to choose how the game will end, it is up to the player to decide which ending is right and wrong and act on that decision.