Custom Story Help

[UnseenLegend ( NL )]

Try to change profile.

So basically create a new profile and see if it works..?

No. some people creating double profiles.
And without noticing it, it wont show on custom stories.

Are you sure you put into the right file? it's basically on
\redist\custom_stories
As you said you were using a non steam version.

Or you downloaded broken custom stories.
If this still not helping you, should give us the hpl.log.