AMFP Member Review Thread

[MyRedNeptune]

Wow, so you find no differences between an inventory and a story?

That wasn't my point at all.

"It had the best fucking story ever" is just about as informative as "This game is stupid because it doesn't have an inventory".

Key word - "informative". Both comments tell me nothing about what might be good or bad in the game. They just tell me that somebody liked the story, and another person disliked that it didn't have an inventory. And that's it, no further comment.

If they'd actually commented on why they think so, their assertations on behalf of the quality of the game might have carried more weight, you know?

Also, are you suggesting that the people who praise the story are "right" simply because they have focused on the story rather than the mechanics, and the story is more important somehow?