AMFP Member Review Thread

[Nice]

I'll share my review but lemme comment on some of yours

All the "I was so dissapointed to not see inventory and CS and tinderboxes, i almost got a heart attack!"

First of all, they already said what the game will NOT have like 1 or 2 months before release and yet people still act shocked about it

Second, you want tinderboxes, oil, terror meter, sanity...What next? Brute? Grunt? Sorry but i believe FG wanted to try out something new otherwise this whole game would be no different than a custom story for amnesia if you know what i mean.

Enough reviewing other reviews

My personal, short review:

I was kinda surprised on how interaction was very limited but then i found out that if it wasnt, the puzzles would be impossible to solve due to no inventory. Think about it, if you could carry and grab EVERY single item in a puzzle game with no inventory...Well..You're in for a rough time.

The puzzles were not hard to solve it was pretty straight forward and quite repetitive. Spin the wheel, insert the cog or insert the battery, dont forget the pull the lever ofc. But then again, this game was not made for strictly puzzle solving so its okay. I bought it to explore a dark world, hear a story and get scared, not to solve puzzles. That's just me.

The music and sounds were TOO dramatic, complex and loud for my taste. For a horror game i prefer simble but disturbing music/ambience playing in the background. ATDD imo completely dominates AAMFP as far as ambience, sounds and music go.

Monster:

The problem here, atleast to me was that the monster was very predictable. Ofc it's a pig, and on top of that, it was the only monster in the game. When i played ATDD i was scared senseless because i did not know what to expect. Is there something that can come out of small openings or ceiling? are there ghosts? and so on and so forth. As for AAMFP i was pretty much prepared, i could safely assume the monster will be either half pig on 2 legs or half pig on 4 legs and was prepared to deal with it once i meet it.

The ending was better than ATDD, although i dont think i fully grasped the story
One type of scare was VERY repetitive, the "monster runs past by" or you get a glimpse for a quick second and then it vanishes.

I dont have time right now to get into great detail, i might edit the post later but to put it in short now:

From my review it might look like i'm completely hating on the game, that's not true. In my review i pointed out the bad stuff but this game has good stuff aswell.

It wasn't better than ATDD at all, but you have to consider the fact that ATDD was extremely beyond awesome.

The game was far from bad or dull, i give it a 7/10.

Here's also something for you whiny piggies that should know: This game was never ment to be something really big, if i'm not mistaken it was ment to be something a bit more than DLC but that's about it. They never planned for it to be something huge, their current project will take place for that.

Anyway, heads up FG and the chinese room i await your next product with excitement