AMFP Member Review Thread

[Thief1337]

Perhaps you also should read more of Thomas thoughts, perhaps after that you will be aware that he loved AAMFP, that he praised the direction they took with Amnesia in the terms of storytelling and gameplay, and that new FG title will be pretty much in the same fashion?

Appreciation does not justify reasoning or actual content (unless you're the bandwagon kind). He can appreciate whatever he wants, but no one can deny ATDD truly was their most creative work. AAMFP is attempted to be based, after all, on ATDD. We all appreciate that effort as well, but no one can deny the creativity behind ATDD that made FG so successful. Removing much of the game mechanics and possible interaction in AAMFP killed the "Amnesia experience".

If Thomas thinks AAMFP is better than ATDD, it's up to him. I could care less. Pink Floyd also loved and showed more appreciation for their commercial Dark Side of the Moon tunes than their first albums, but we all know what's the best after all.