If AMFP would be released before TDD, would you feel diffrent about it?

[Doomed316]

The idea is how would tou feel about AMFP if you didn't have TDD to compare, as a standalone game on it's own. it's a diffrent game with diffrent characters and story and mechanics and was made by a diffrent company, if you severe connections to TDD, is it better or worse?

I would think that the game would have built upon what it had already had. Seeing a machine for pigs felt like a stripped down version of TDD, playing AAMFP before TDD would show that the devs were adding onto what they already know. However if you take into account of penumbra, you would see that people would say "penumbra was so awesome and not so linear." I would take penumbra in account first