Should Soma be more like Penumbra or The Walking Dead?

[baelmont3leet]

Do you want a game with a lot of good and satisfying puzzles to solve, or one that is just a story on rails with some scares?

Personally, I thought Penumbra was better than Amnesia solely because I enjoyed solving the puzzles a lot more. I'm hoping Soma doesn't dumb the puzzles down to cater to a wider audience.

I'm hoping for some combat or its going to be a game I pass up I cant find any redeemable quality to a game that just has the player run and hide its not scary to me if thats all you do... puzzles seem like a filler or waste of time its ok to have a few but with no combat and all puzzles and running and hiding playing tag in the dark is a headache at best Im sure there are a few out there that find that type of gameplay enjoyable and if this is indeed the route they go good for them but I will not participate in this game if its only quality is scare tactics and running and hiding with no combat even a simple shove or push would give it a +1