Overture stuff vs Black Plague stuff

[BendyBread]

To me, BP was more scary due to all the corridoors and naked men trying to kill you that were running around.
To me, Overture had a superior storyline and I liked the wolves. I don't know, it just seemed slightly more realistic to me, to be trapped in an underground cave/mining industry rather than awakening inside some massive secret complex underground. Overture was less scary in my mind, but certainly had a fantastic atmosphere and the puzzles were fun for me.

Thats just me though, and both games are fantastic in my eyes.