Too Scary; Does It exist?

[superluser]

Scary is a subjective experience. To the extent that something can be scary for all humans (and I suspect that that is possible at the very least by stimulating certain parts of the brain), I doubt that a game could do it.

On the other hand, I am compelled to believe that a particular game could be too scary for any given person.

Else I would have to believe that any game I play would always be safe enough to never truly terrify me, and I would never have to fear that the game that I'm playing would be too terrifying, thus reducing my scared reactions to any particular game.