Just finished Amnesia and....

[Darkchef]

Okay, after having finished Amnesia and all 3 Penumbra games (2+1), this is my personal ranking of those games:

1. Amnesia
Scariest game I've ever seen and played! Might re-play this game now that I finished the Penumbra games.

2. Penumbra - Black Plague
Very scary and creepy at some parts, but it lacked a little bit intensity and surprises. But maybe that's just because I've played it after Amnesia.

3. Penumbra - Overture
It was very scary early on when the first dogs appeared, jeez. But then...later on I was able to handle the weapons a bit better and could safely kill all dogs while standing on boxes, etc. The weapons made the game a lot less scarier.

3. Penumbra - Requiem
Some nice puzzles, but the game itself wasn't scary at all, unfortunately...finished it in 3 hours.

I would say about the same, requiem just seems rather pointless to me...