Similar Horror Games

[Kman]

I have a few, but I don't know what you've done so far, so sorry if I've listed games you've already played. XD
-Amnesia (and Justine DLC package)
-Penumbra Series (Both of which you're already doing).
-Dead Space 1 & 2
-Fear
-Silent Hill (possibly)
-Undying

How is dead space like amnesia at all... what makes it scary (and I use scary VERY VERY lightly) is constant jump scares and gallons of blood everywhere. And with dead space 2 the developers even said themselves they were gonna make it more action based than horror. So comparing it to amnesia, a game that uses sounds, atomousphere, and pure dread to make it scary doesn't make any sense...

That's just my opinion of course, you can think whatever you want. As for what game you should play i've heard the first 3 resident evils were pretty good, and of course the silent hill series.