It might be a different experience, but not necessarily in a negative way. I'm not convinced that it will ruin the atmosphere, though. The most
horrific reaction video on YouTube (in which the guy ends up
crying!) was taken from a Skype play-through. There were
several other guys playing with him, in fact. It didn't seem to help the guy's nerves that his friends were online with him, joking around etc. Same goes for the "that's not traditional fire" video; it was a Skype recording featuring multiple players and the guy
still went crazy.
Go for it bartecolls! If you record the play-through share the link so we can see how it went