In the light or in the dark? What's your play choice?

[vaxoxen]

In the dark with headphones really does give you the amnesia experience you deserve

I did the whole game and the first few mods like this and it was amazing! I can't be bothered to do it any more as all the mods I have left now seem to be about half hour long and it's hard to build up the atmosphere in that time

But seriously, I wouldn't say it makes it any scarier as such, it just absorbs you into the game/atmosphere much more.

What I don't recommend is playing with headphones with the volume right up; man did I have a heard attack XD

[Fomzo]

Why, the dark, obviously. I see no point in playing Amnesia in the light.

100% Agree

[A Luna]

I played it in the dark + headset + at midnight.

After 20 minutes of playing like that I took off my headset and lighted it up a little. Then continued. I'm scared

[Yuhaney]

When the game was first released I waited 'till sun went down and then fired the game up. So, I'd say that in the dark.

[Gharren]

I mostly play in the dark, but on really terrifying parts I need the lights to be on.
Maybe a poll would be cool to have an overall view.

[darkely]

The dark is a little more creepier but all and all it is not that big of a deal.

[she]

I've always played it in the dark, but last night I tried playing by candlelight and found that it really added to the creepy ambiance.

[BrooksyFC]

In the dark, with a candle as my only light source. Headphones and some peanuts (Just to add to effect of going insane, as it sounds like Daniel is eating something)

[Unearthlybrutal]

At night, with headphones, without any light...

( ...with a lot of cigarettes and coffee )

[Nice]

At the dawn