+- Frictional Games Forum (read-only) (https://www.frictionalgames.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Frictional Games (https://www.frictionalgames.com/forum/forum-3.html)
+--- Forum: Off-Topic (https://www.frictionalgames.com/forum/forum-16.html)
+--- Thread: Penumbra the Movie : Who would be your ideal cast ? (/thread-2461.html)
Penumbra the Movie : Who would be your ideal cast ? - Petike - 11-19-2008
Just for fun : If a Penumbra movie was ever to be created, who would you cast for the roles of Philip, Red, Swanson, Eminiss, Howard, etc. ?
Feel free to make suggestions.
RE: Penumbra the Movie : Who would be your ideal cast ? - eliasfrost - 11-19-2008
Arnold as Philip.
Chuck as Red.
RE: Penumbra the Movie : Who would be your ideal cast ? - Tommy Gun - 11-19-2008
hmmm, i reckon, maybe as phillip, somone with greying hair, 30 -40ish, huh, i dunno.
for red, because we never actusally see him, maybe keep the person who did the games, maybe have him in the shadows.
RE: Penumbra the Movie : Who would be your ideal cast ? - Guyra - 11-19-2008
Tim Robbins as Phillip, perhaps...
And I'd say Red should be played as the same guy who did the voices. In my opinion, it should be like in the games, that you don't see him.
RE: Penumbra the Movie : Who would be your ideal cast ? - Petike - 11-26-2008
Guyra Wrote:Tim Robbins as Phillip, perhaps...
Yeah, the problem is, you shouldn't see too many people in the movie either - it should respect the game's enigmatic and paranoid atmosphere...
Tim Robbins ? Not a bad choice, but he's simply too old.
We need a 30-something year old British bloke... :-)
If you'd want A-class actors known to world audiences, then...
Philip : Cillian Murphy wouldn't be too far fetched. The guy's a talent, played all sorts of odd characters until now, can fake an English (28 Days Later) and American accent (Sunshine, Batman Begins), is slightly over 30 and looks somewhat geeky (as Phil should be, 'cause he's a physics scientist ;-) ). One annoying thing would be those smarmy eyes of his, though...
Amabel Swanson : Rose Byrne. :-D Nuff' said. ;-) Besides her death, she should show up in a few scenes from the BP timeline - perhaps when contacting Philip via the camera system. The scenes should partly show her working on an antidote for the virus, and taking a regular look at the makeshift barricades to her office (with the Infected trying to break in).
Red : I agree, Red should exist only in the form of voice-over, done by no one else, than Mike Hillard himself. :-)
As for the others... Who knows...
Creatures should be part CGI, part prostethics (if possible) and should show up only rarely - and when they do, it has to be unexpected and intense...
RE: Penumbra the Movie : Who would be your ideal cast ? - spukrian - 11-27-2008
I´ve said this before, but I´d like Rebecca Mader to do Amabel Swanson!
RE: Penumbra the Movie : Who would be your ideal cast ? - Petike - 11-30-2008
spukrian Wrote:I´ve said this before, but I´d like Rebecca Mader to do Amabel Swanson!
Hey, I'm not argueing... ;-D
RE: Penumbra the Movie : Who would be your ideal cast ? - Umbra - 11-30-2008
Well, I think there is no reason to make a film based on Penumbra. Penumbra is more than video game - it's more like a book with good story and philosophic end, last letter of Philip is a real revelation,,,
RE: Penumbra the Movie : Who would be your ideal cast ? - Petike - 11-30-2008
Umbra Wrote:Well, I think there is no reason to make a film based on Penumbra. Penumbra is more than video game - it's more like a book with good story and philosophic end, last letter of Philip is a real revelation,,,
I fully agree on that, Umbra. To be honest, Penumbra would not be good source material for a movie. And if someone nonetheless came up with an ASB idea of making one, it would have to be more of a indie horror to be interesting at all...
Besides, movies based on games and games based on movies usualy... SUCK... I think the main reason for that, is the fact that one medium tries to compete with the other in presentation or storytelling... and fails...
RE: Penumbra the Movie : Who would be your ideal cast ? - Petike - 11-30-2008
nackidno Wrote:Arnold as Philip.
Arnie as Philip :
"Uuuhhh... See zis big pickaxe, doggies ?! I gonna kick ya arsch ! Astala vista !" :-DDD
Chuck "Red" Redwood jokes :
Red isn't dillusional, when he speaks to you. Philip is dillusional in Requiem, and listens to the all-knowing Red.
Red likes to sleep with the incinerator turned on, so he can have more light. That doesn't mean, that Red is affraid of the dark. The dark is affraid of him.
While Red was searching the two dead bodies on Lake Utuquaq, he was "almost swallowed whole" under the ice. If that would happen, the water would not be water anymore. It would be weird-accent-Red-mega-uber-coolness...
;-)))