Amnesia Doesn't Scare Me...

[Wooderson]

I think everyone has really been trying to defend Amnesia, as Amnesia wouldn't really be much if it wasn't scary... And because the OP is one of the only people to say it doesn't scare them, it seems like he's putting the game down if you know what I mean.

From reading everything... The OP has played Amnesia to a winning tactic (I.E taking advantage of enemies poor A.I) I wouldn't call that immersing yourself properly.

When I play horror games, I don't shout or scream out loud which people tend to do on videos... Instead I show my fear through sweat, loss of stability, and my heart pounds. And Amnesia makes me do all of those. If it doesn't make you do any of those then I have no idea what has gone wrong.