Amnesia Doesn't Scare Me...

[Carrna]

I also know a dude who seems not to get scared of anything. No matter how scary horror movies we watch or play horror games and everyone else in the room gets scared and later see nightmares, he won't. People are afraid of different things, more or less than others.

It's also true that player's attitude can have it's effect but if there's absolutely nothing in the game that the player is really scared of it's quite useless. However, it's natural and quite common to be afraid of the dark, not to mention mutilated, walking corpses. If, let's say, about 90% of players get scared while playing Amnesia, I wouldn't call the game a failure or those players as pussies.

It's just impossible to please everyone.