Which game did you find scarier?

[The Rock Worm]

After hearing all of your comments, I tend to agree that Amnesia is scarier than the other games. I did get scared and plenty nervous in Amnesia 1.

What would be good and scary to play is one with a direct Lovecraft universe locations/people/monsters.

Unfortunately H.P. Lovecraft is a cult phenomenon (even though he is considered one of the finest American writers ever) and so there are never going to be big budget companies throwing their money at a Lovecraftian game pitch. Call of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of the Earth is about as close as you get though it's not modeled after any story in particular.

@TheRockWorm: Why don't you just play it? You've made a lot of threads and posts on here asking about how true it is and what not. Why don't you just decide for yourself?

I would love to play it, but things are busy at my end so I can't really buy it.
Besides, the Frictional Games Penumbra and Amnesia are Lovecraftian-like.

Still... I will find a demo for starters.