Amnesia = One of the Best Games Ever

[BendyBread]

It's a great game. Immersion is top notch, definitely shit scary to me and the plot was decently strong.

But no, not one the 'best games' to me personally. Bioshock 1 (and 2, that gets lots of flak but I genuinely enjoyed that), HL 2 + episodes, Alan Wake, and probably a bunch of others.
Don't get me wrong, I loved the game to bits, but for me it wasn't top 10 list material (and I'm generally not a shooter type player, so to have so many in my list is weird).