SOLVED - New user profile/game wrote over my other profile!

[kirkmegna]

If you clicked Continue there is a small bug in which steam restores the dates wrong of something. Just load an earlier save manually.

Thanks Plutomaniac! In my moment of panic I looked over being able to load a game.

I also discovered another solution. By going into User Documents, into the Amnesia folder > Pig > Profile Name I was able to delete the save-files that were "most recent" but from the start of the game.

After that I was able to "Continue" from where I left off.