Disappointed with AAMFP

[XDamienDaKillaX]

Seriously disappointed in this game. The game itself is not bad. Great story, voice acting, graphics, game mechanics etc. However I would not call it amnesia for it does not have nearly the same level of fear associated with AMFP as TDD has. I was expecting to be horrified and paly for 10 minutes at a time like TDD. Nope could play for a couple hours with the scariest part being solving the next "puzzle." TDD had that atmosphere where opening every door was a challenge itself and the use of the lantern and tinderboxes provided a fear itself if you ran out of oil or tinderboxes. All the waiting and anticipation for an even scarier game than TDD was all that kept me from being pissed off for the delays. Turns out the delays may have ruined what had the potential to be the scariest game on the PC. I know this thread will get negative ratings but im just throwing in my 2 cents. Please frictional games do another indie horror game and bring back the true fear of playing a game worthy of the Amnesia title.
All in all I would take a refund if I could get it.
AMFP 3/10
TDD 9/10

... what you said about the game does not justify a 3/10..... This is what I got from you.

Pros about AMFP:
Great Story
Great Voice Acting
Great Graphics
Great Game Mechanics

Any game that is great in those areas (aside from voice acting, it isn't too much of a big deal) is a great game. You don't get many that are great in those catergories.....
And then you rate the game 3/10 because it wasn't scary enough...? AND you want a refund? Gotta say, to me it sounds like you only care about horror in an Amnesia game. Amnesia isn't just horror, its the great things you yourself mentioned. There's no way what you said warrants a 3/10.