Amnesia VS Penumbra

[AMV Ph34r]

Just wait till they make a gmod version of amnesia.

Oh man, that would be great XD
Though that would be about as far from scary as possible: "Oh, a monster? Pff, I'll just spawn an explosive barrel here, aaaaannnndd dead."

[DIGI Byte]

hahah oh man, ok, Asylum that I refereed to is a amnesia mod, currently being worked on by 2 people, possibly 3, myself included, there is a horror game coming out soon, that im looking forward too, I believe its on the 360 though, and it looks damn good

and monsters in Gmod, you bet it, wouldn't surprise me if they are trying to convert/compile them now

[AMV Ph34r]

Ohhhh, cool. Can't wait to see it!

[b0bbe]

I'm gonna answer the question without reading ALL the post.

I like them both. But Amnesia is my favourite.

[BlueFury]

Just wait till they make a gmod version of amnesia.

Oh man, that would be great XD
Though that would be about as far from scary as possible: "Oh, a monster? Pff, I'll just spawn an explosive barrel here, aaaaannnndd dead."

there already are mods for gmod, the infected and the gasmask

[les paul166]

I prefered amnesia for scares, but penumbra for story... but the last episode to penumbra was boring and could have been done alot better i think.

DAMMIT! i went out and had a choice between all the games and i just grabbed Overture. Gaaah

[ChoskarChulian]

My preference is Amnesia.
Although Penumbra had the scariest moments, they kind of went like "dah dah dah DUFF dah dah DUFF dah DUFF dah dah DUFF" etc.
While as Amnesia was more "DUFF DUFF DUFF DUFF dah DUFF" etc.

LOL what? XD
This made me ROFL

[Henriksen]

I think that Penumbra was the most memorable, dunno why but I really felt connected to

Spoiler below!

Tom Redwood, and when he went into the incinerator I felt really guiltly :C

. Anyway, I thought that Amnesia was a scarier game overall, but that was what they were aiming to do this time, whilst the Penumbra series wanted to create a athmosphere where everything is unknown and you really feel helpless. Overture didnt quite nail that concept as you could easily kill the dogs with your weapons. But Black Plauge, what can I say: OMGWTFBBQ!

[skypeskype]

I prefer Amnesia. Its way more scarier than Penumbra also the atmosphere and overall level design is better. I play Amnesia with 1.1 gamma. I think its perfect.

[Brennenburg]

One of my favourite things about Penumbra was Clarence.